The Index




August 22, 2023

The Best Platforms To Start An Online Membership In 2023

More like this:

The Best Platforms To Start An Online Membership In 2023


This free guide will get you 100% clear on your community idea, so you can stop overthinking, and start earning 🚀 



The rise of the digital age has brought forth numerous opportunities for creators, educators, and community leaders to connect with their audiences and monetize their content through online memberships. As the demand for exclusive and premium content grows, platforms catering to this need have emerged. This article delves into a comprehensive comparison of some of the leading platforms for starting an online membership: Patreon, OnlyFans, Circle, Kajabi, Mighty Networks, and MemberUp.


MemberUp is a customizable platform where you can host and monetize your courses, content, and community, all in one beautiful place, without the tech headache.

No more duct taping together your content, courses, community, and payments- you’re better than that.  MemberUp has all the tools you need to build a thriving community – all in one beautifully designed place. 


  • User-friendly interface for easy setup.
  • Ability to host events, courses, as well as chat spaces, and direct messaging for your members
  • Innovative features like Spark that post “done for you” questions every 24 hours.
  • Manage your content and your community in one place
  • Integration with popular payment gateways.
  • Custom branding and the ability to choose between light and dark theme
  • Constant improvements and feature updates
  • Access to MemberUp University


Patreon is a pioneer in the online membership space, offering creators a platform to connect with their supporters, or “patrons,” and provide them with exclusive content. Known for its versatility, Patreon supports various content types, including videos, podcasts, illustrations, and written work. Creators can set up multiple tiers of membership, each offering different perks to patrons, such as early access, behind-the-scenes content, and Q&A sessions. Patreon charges a fee, which includes both a platform fee and payment processing fees.


  • Established and widely recognized platform.
  • Diverse content types and membership tiers.
  • Integration with popular third-party tools.


  • Patreon’s fees can impact earnings.
  • Very little ability to customize the design
  • Operates like a one way feed so your members can only comment on your posts 


Primarily known for its association with adult content, OnlyFans has expanded to accommodate a wider range of creators, including artists, writers, fitness trainers, and more. It allows creators to monetize their content through subscriptions, pay-per-view posts, and tips from fans. While it may carry some stigma due to its history, OnlyFans offers a space for creators to establish a direct relationship with their audience.


  • Simple to use.
  • Direct connection between creators and audience.
  • Growing acceptance for non-adult content.


  • Previous reputation for adult content might impact perception.
  • Limited customization options for branding.


Circle is a community platform that emphasizes engagement and interaction. It enables creators to build their membership-based communities with features like discussion boards, direct messaging, and content sharing. Circle’s focus on fostering meaningful connections and conversation sets it apart from platforms primarily centered around content delivery.


  • Emphasis on community engagement.
  • Dedicated space for discussions and interactions.
  • Integration with other tools for content creation.


  • May require active moderation to maintain a positive community atmosphere.
  • Limited payment options compared to other platforms.
  • Limited customization and design 


Kajabi is an all-in-one platform designed for online course creation, membership sites, and digital product sales. It offers robust features for course content delivery, marketing, and sales, making it suitable for educators and professionals aiming to provide structured learning experiences to their members.


  • Comprehensive suite of tools for content creation and marketing.
  • Customizable membership sites with branding options.
  • Advanced analytics and marketing automation.


  • May be overkill for creators focused solely on membership-based content.
  • Higher pricing compared to some other platforms.

Mighty Networks

Mighty Networks focuses on building niche communities around shared interests. It allows creators to combine membership monetization with community building, offering features such as forums, events, and member networking. This platform is ideal for creators who want to create a dedicated space for enthusiasts to connect.


  • Strong community-building features.
  • Ability to organize events and discussions.
  • Niche-focused approach enhances engagement.


  • May lack the content variety of other platforms.
  • Learning curve for setting up and managing a community.

Ready to build an extraordinary community?

MemberUp is a customizable platform where you can host and monetize your courses, content, and community, all in one beautiful place, without the tech headache.

We offer the flexibility to create a membership experience that’s truly yours. Ideal for subscription, memberships + gated exclusive content. If you’re ready to embark on the journey of creating your very own membership site, start today at 

Comments +

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Unlock MemberUp


Enter your details below to instantly receive a full platform demo + details of our next creator intake 🚀